Rural communication: Is there still a need for telecentres now that there are mobile phones?
Hi all, this study was conducted by APC, comparing the role of mobile phones and telecentres in fostering rural development.
It is noted that mobile phone towers dominate the landscape of many countries where decent internet access still remains a dream. The Economist argues that mobile is all that matters now and many donors have succumbed to this vision, retreating en-masse from rural information and communication technology development. The author of the new report commissioned by APC concludes that "This has left the development of ICTs in the hands of large, highly-centralized telecoms."
APCNews however looks at the rationale behind getting internet into rural areas via wireless and not leaving it all to mobile, and reports back on real-life community efforts that have been taking internet access to parts of Latin America ignored by large companies.
MONTEVIDEO (Ian Howard for APCNews) argued that following the initial rush of information and communication technologies for development (ICT4D) projects in rural Africa, many did not yield the anticipated outcomes, and interest has been dying down. People then began talking about "sustainable ICT" projects that would become self-sufficient after their initial set-up period. But with mobile phones gaining in popularity, popular rhetoric has begun to question the need of ICTs beyond the mobile phone. While mobiles have had a great impact in rural areas, a new study by Ian Howard, commissioned by APC, argues that the need for telecentres and affordable internet connections exists, as such centres cater to rural and niche markets the way larger companies cannot.
What is your take on this? Please share your views with us.
Sandra
It is noted that mobile phone towers dominate the landscape of many countries where decent internet access still remains a dream. The Economist argues that mobile is all that matters now and many donors have succumbed to this vision, retreating en-masse from rural information and communication technology development. The author of the new report commissioned by APC concludes that "This has left the development of ICTs in the hands of large, highly-centralized telecoms."
APCNews however looks at the rationale behind getting internet into rural areas via wireless and not leaving it all to mobile, and reports back on real-life community efforts that have been taking internet access to parts of Latin America ignored by large companies.
MONTEVIDEO (Ian Howard for APCNews) argued that following the initial rush of information and communication technologies for development (ICT4D) projects in rural Africa, many did not yield the anticipated outcomes, and interest has been dying down. People then began talking about "sustainable ICT" projects that would become self-sufficient after their initial set-up period. But with mobile phones gaining in popularity, popular rhetoric has begun to question the need of ICTs beyond the mobile phone. While mobiles have had a great impact in rural areas, a new study by Ian Howard, commissioned by APC, argues that the need for telecentres and affordable internet connections exists, as such centres cater to rural and niche markets the way larger companies cannot.
What is your take on this? Please share your views with us.
Sandra
Replies to This Discussion
-
Permalink Reply by Macarena Díaz von der Hundt on -
Hi Sandra, as I told you by mail yesterday, we reproduced this discucion in the spanish site. The reaction was amazing. Certainly it is a mayor subject, spetialy because in LAC countries mobile phones do have a big impact as well. I'm sure you will be intrested in following the spanish discussion.
greetings
Macarena
-
Permalink Reply by Sandra Nassali on -
Will surely follow up- though with no skills what so ever in Spanish :-)
Sandra
-
Permalink Reply by Marco Figueiredo on -
I read a bit of the Spanish discussion and it adds new and interesting outlooks into the question.
-
Permalink Reply by Dean Mulozi on -
Hi Sandra,
This resource may be useful in our knowledge sharing expriences. Alhtough it was done for Plan international, most of the chapters could be useful. - Attachments:
-
Permalink Reply by Sandra Nassali on
-
Thank you Dean, will have a look at it.
-
Permalink Reply by Marco Figueiredo on
-
Check this report on Mobiles for Development:
http://www.plan.fi/uploads/media/Mobiles_for_Development_-_Plan_200...
"this report for Plan International looks at the
potential of mobile technologies for enhancing development in Africa.
Although the tech side will be nothing new to most, you may be
interested in the socio-technical process
that was developed for their staff to think through how they might use
mobiles, and for what."
Quick Links
Latest Activity
This group is all about efforts by individuals and corporations all over the globe who strive to use ICT based media to ensure sustainable agriculture,environmental conservation,food security,social entrepreneurship thrives unfettered.
With networks in 22 countries across the Middle East and Africa, mobile operator Zain has commenced commercial services in Ghana with the launch of the first 3.5G wireless network on the continent outside South Africa. Zain Ghana’s network will of...
Modern technologies of ICT and telecentres
are very helpful for both men and women.But
it may be more useful to learn the actual
status of efficacy for the development of
societies through the telecentre related
technologies.
Telecentres are providing immense services to the promotion of education.Students of all disciplines and societies use the various services of telecentres for their assignments and communications.We may highlight educational activities in this group.
Thanks Fredrick for the information
I would like to know about any green projects that use ICT innovatively.
http://www.solutions-site.org/artman/publish/
http://www.cpcp.org.my
http://www.worldwithoutoil.org/
What would be the role in Telecen...
A coordination space for people working on the telecentre.org Academy, a global initiative to provide telecentre managers with ongoing training, capacity building, and professional development opportunities.
A place for community members to get involved with producing newspapers that report on the people, ideas, and activities that fuel the global telecentre movement.
One of the main challenges facing telecentres over the years is how to achieve sustainability, a critical element in the long-term development of telecentres and their networks. While several initiatives have emerged to promote telecentre sustaina...
One of the main challenges facing telecentres over the years is how to achieve sustainability, a critical element in the long-term development of telecentres and their networks. While several initiatives have emerged to promote telecentre sustaina...
Telecentre Leaders' Forum MENA – Mashreq Region
Amman 15-16 July 2009
The purpose of the event is to convene telecentre practitioners and development partners from the Eastern MENA region (Mashreq) to share experiences and develop plans for stren...
Mission2011: Building a Sustainable ICT-Based Information and Knowledge System for the Poor and the Marginalised by the 40th Anniversary of Bangladesh's Independence
Thank you for your participation. In Bangladesh we are working for both financial and social sustainability. I believe social sustainability is more important than financial sustainability for a telecentre as a social enterprise. Community people ...
Urban and community forestry too can make a difference in our lives. Each one of us can make a personal contribution. As we develop and apply technologies for a better way of life, often times side effects adversely affect our natural environment....
In addition to what I have already said, I think the telecentre community can also contribute to this movement. Since the telecentres are, by and large, catering to the needs of the rural population, they can also take upon themselves the responsi...
Hi Owino,
I checked out the websites suggested by you and found them really interesting. Alan Foo's suggestions are equally interesting and valuable. We have done so much damage to the planet that we have to think about a thousand ideas to set eve...
© 2009 Created by telecentre.org
